To my dearest subscribers,
Shalom! If you are a New Yorker, then you had a hot, humid week. If you are not, you may have had a hot, humid week, but it probably wasn’t as bad as in New York. But, thanks to modern day technology, we can condition the air to any temperature that we would like (at least indoors), and I am sitting in a very comfortable, cool room. I once heard a story with Rav Moshe Feinstein. When air conditioners first came out, they asked Rav Moshe if he wanted one. After thinking about it, he said he doesn’t want one. “Why not?,” they asked. “It may help my learning when I am sitting in the air conditioned room. But when I don’t have the air conditioning, I won’t be able to concentrate. Right now, I can concentrate without the A/C. So I don’t need it.” (That’s not a direct quote, but I hope I captured the essence of what he said. In other words, “If it ain’t broke, why fix it?”) So take that!
In the first of this week’s two parshiyot (Matot and Masei), there is a very interesting story with two and a half of the 12 Jewish tribes. The tribes of Gad, Reuven, and half of Menashe approached Moshe and said that they don’t want to enter the land of Israel. Instead, they want to remain on the east bank of the Jordan River and set up camp there. Why? Because they were shepherds, they had a lot of cattle, and the land to the east of Israel is better for grazing than Israel itself. When they told this to Moshe, he bashed them (for a good reason, of course). He tells them, “Do you know what happened with your parents? During the time of your parents, at the beginning of our 40-year voyage in the desert, spies went into the land and reported that the land was bad. This caused a whole turmoil, and Hashem told them that they can’t enter Israel because of their negative attitude. Now, you – Gad, Reuven, and half of Menashe – are going to get this started again. The other tribes will feel that you don’t want to enter Israel because you are afraid of the nations therein, and then they will refuse to enter the land, as well. “Behold, you have risen up in the place of your fathers, a society of sinful people, to add more to the burning wrath of Hashem against Israel. For if you will turn away from after Him, He will again let [the Jews] rest in the Wilderness, and you will destroy this entire people” (Bamidbar 32:14-15).
So they reply, “We will set up cities for our families, but we will continue with the rest of the nation, into the land, to fight the wars with the rest of the nation.” By offering to come along until they completely conquer the land, they would no longer create fear in the hearts of their brothers. They are gung-ho, fighting the same war, even though they won’t even be living in this land! This would prevent a huge disaster, which would be inevitable, because history repeats itself. Moshe responds, if you do this, “then you will be vindicated from Hashem and from [the Jews]…” (Bamidbar 32:22). Simple understanding of the passuk (in my humble opinion) is that they will be vindicated from both Hashem and from the Jews because, potentially, they would have sinned against both Hashem (if you will turn away from after Him) and the Jews (will destroy this entire people), as mentioned in 32:15.
Another understanding of how they would be sinning against the Jews is they wouldn’t be fighting in the war with their brothers. They would abandon their brothers before entering the land. That would be sinning against them. But now that they decided to come along and fight, they are vindicated in brothers’ eyes, as well.
However, the gemara in Masechet Yoma (38a) and the Yerushalmi (Shekalim 3:2) learn this another way. Moshe tells these nations that they must prove to Hashem that they don’t have negative intentions. They must prove that they don’t want to speak ill against the land or spark any fears amongst the rest of the Jews. However, vindicating themselves in the eyes of Hashem isn’t enough; they must also clear themselves of any suspicion amongst the human beings, as well. One must be careful not to engender suspicion on human beings. He must vindicate himself from them, too. It must be clear to the rest of the nation that they did not have intention to sin.
My question is, Why? Why do I have to care if someone else thinks I’m a sinner? If I am doing what’s correct, and Hashem knows that I am doing what’s correct, then why do I have to make sure to clear my name in other people’s eyes? Is that even a possible feat? I can’t be worried about what others think about me!
Although this is true, to an extent, because it is impossible to make sure everyone in the world thinks you are perfect, when you do something to warrant those negative thoughts, you must undo your damage. In other words, these tribes are deciding to go against the plans. Others will now think that there is something wrong with Israel. Even if you aren’t against the land of Israel, you can still begin turmoil, and you must see that. Sometimes, a person will only do something if someone else does it first. There can be forbidden sin that no one would ever think of doing. But as soon as you do it, you have just opened the doors for others to follow your lead. By saying that they don’t want to enter Israel, it’s possible that others who were having the same thought will not enter Israel either.
Similarly, for us, if you do something wrong, you may be giving others the necessary precedent to sin, as well. It is for this reason that you must clear your name. Not because you care what others think of you – but because you don’t want to be partially responsible for his sin. You don’t want to be that kind of negative role-model.
One example is, let’s say you give someone the cold shoulder, and ignore him, but for good reason. Let’s say, you had to run because someone needed your help, so you ran to help your friend, but in the whilst, you ignored someone else. Now, if you realize that you did this, you should go back to him and explain why you did what you did. Why? Who cares what he thinks? I know that I was doing the right thing! The answer is that this might cause him to give you the cold shoulder, be in a bad mood, and give the next guy a cold shoulder, as well. And you don’t want to be responsible for that. [This isn’t the best example, I acknowledge that, but I’m not perfect. Sorry.]
May we all be sensitive and think thoroughly about everything we do. And if we do something that others might take the wrong way, may we realize that and clear our names of suspicion so that others will not act incorrectly because of us.
Shabbat Shalom, and enjoy your air conditioning!
Always and Forever,
Avraham Adam Sabzevari